Book Review: Breaking Money Silence: How to Shatter Money Taboos, Talk More Openly about Finances and Live a Richer Life by Kathleen Burns Kingsbury
Written by: Mary Liz Burns, MBA, FBS®, AFC® Candidate
“Silent but deadly.” This chapter title of Kathleen Burns Kingsbury’s second edition of Breaking Money Silence called to mind how women display different health symptoms than men in heart attacks and strokes. When some medical professionals are dismissive and unaware of gender differences, women learn to downplay the pain and be silent—with terrible consequences. Thanks to strong advocacy and more headlines, there is a push to recognize women’s symptoms and ask better questions. Can we take this approach to address one of the leading causes of stress in our lives and in our personal relationships: money silence? We can do better, and thanks to Kingsbury, we have a solid roadmap on how to change this story.
Kingsbury, author of several books, a money mindset and advisor coach and mentor to female entrepreneurs, challenges all of us to help break the one of the last taboos in society- money. This “is a book about how to stop keeping your thoughts and feelings about money to yourself.” The author knows that silence is ingrained in our personal history. Her upbringing demonstrated money silence when it came to making money and talking about success and profit as a woman. It was fine to talk about how much she saved but not how much she earned.
Kingsbury structures the book with two main sections. The first exposes the true price of money silence in our families, in couples, with kids and parents, and in perpetuating myths that support gender bias. The financial industry is not blameless in the perpetuation of silence, according to the author. The rise in the number of advisors who are weaving in understanding the human side of money into their practice propels the importance and urgency of this book’s messages.
The second section provides a roadmap to recognize and acquire the necessary skills to break money taboos. Each chapter ends with “Money Talk Challenges” that provide opportunities to practice new skills, such as identifying your money mindset, modeling active listening, and preparing for a money talk with your parents. The challenges make this book actionable and relatable and a good resource for practitioners.
Let’s explore some of the most vexing questions and discover what the author offers as compelling proof:
What harm does money silence truly cause?
Kingsbury talks about the major indicators of harm, including: 88% of adults are stressed about money; 38% of divorcing couples cite financial conflict as leading cause; 70% of families do not pass down wealth to future generations partially due to money silence; and women are undervalued in the workplace. Our relationships, career growth, and overall financial resiliency are negatively impacted by silence.
What role do financial professionals play in money silence?
It is not only the public who buys into the many myths about money and gender, but also financial professionals. Kingsbury debunks myths that affect how the industry markets to and communicates with men and women, such as women are risk averse and struggle with financial literacy, and men are financially savvy and are confident investors. The financial industry continues to lag in recruiting women and promoting women-owned companies. Communicating about money and being more curious with clients about money histories are not “softer skills.” Rather, these are critical competencies that will translate into deeper loyalty with your financial advisor. We should seek financial professionals who embrace these types of conversations and are trained to help us break the money silence in our lives.
Is it truly never too early or too late to break money silence?
In her chapter about teaching children how to be financially intelligent, Kingsbury provides tips on how to start the dialogue at any age even if money silence has been the norm. With examples she uses about marriage, divorce, death, raising kids and talking with parents, the common thread of talking about money is that starting now is key. The author provides helpful models to recognize and potentially change your money mindset if your relationship with money is causing stress—and these “Mind Over Money” methods include a fascinating step to test each money script to see if it is a rational fact or an individual belief. How often do we think about where our money beliefs come from, and challenge the deep-rooted impact that they have on our behavior?
One of my favorite chapters is focused on how we can raise financially fit parents. In my previous work for AARP as the lead communications strategist in financial security, I saw how difficult it is for children to talk with their parents about their finances, especially in the context of legacy planning or with unexpected medical diagnoses. Kingsbury shares that 73% of Americans have not had extensive financial conversations with their aging parents, and some children feel it is none of their business. If parents are not talking, siblings are not talking either. Sadly, statistics show that money silence is one of the key reasons that family relationships fail after the parents pass away.
The author provides thoughtful tips to consider when discussing financial matters with your parents, including identify and process your feelings before the conversation; talk during a quiet time—not during the holidays when things are hectic; be specific about your concerns and keep the conversations brief; and, my personal favorite based on my experience, to give your parent control whenever possible. Aging and money are difficult subjects to talk about as a family; being empathetic and curious are important skills to learn for these conversations.
The “Kingsbury Rules for Fair Financial Conversations” help the reader prepare for “healthy money talk,” and what may be routine practices for you may not be true of your partner.
- Rule #1: Be respectful.
- Rule #2: Use “I” statements.
- Rule #3: Listen actively.
- Rule #4 (Hard one for me!): Don’t mind-read.
- Rule #5: Practice curiosity.
- Rule #6: Agree to disagree.
- Rule #7: Reward yourself for having the conversation.
Families, parents, partners, children, and curious financial professionals can all benefit from the author’s coaching exercises that help us break the cycle of silence. None of us are born knowing how to talk about money. We must train to have effective financial conversations with our loved ones. As I like to say, “practice makes it possible.”
One of my personal heroines from my home state, Dolly Parton, was quoted as saying, “If you don’t like the road you’re walking, start paving another one.” Dolly was not afraid to articulate her value, fight for what she was worth, promote other women artists and leaders, and share many beautiful stories of her personal experience through powerful ballads and music beloved by generations. She was revolutionary in her work, and she was not silent. Kingsbury encourages her readers to join the revolution to break down the walls of money silence. I for one have signed up.
Mary Liz Burns, MBA, is a financial psychology consultant and coach, an Accredited Financial Counselor® Candidate, a Certified Financial Behavior Specialist® and Founder of MaryLizBurns.Money. Connect with Mary Liz on LinkedIn to learn more about her services and expertise.